6 Reasons why service industry process improvement is different to manufacturing

 

Why do Professionals working in process improvement find the transition from manufacturing to service sectors so challenging? Is it simply down to cultural differences or is there more to it? Can the practices and principles of continuous improvement be transitioned across the different industries successfully?

Over the past 10 years, I have witnessed differing levels of success when service organisations have attempted to implement Operational Excellence tools, techniques and methodologies which originated in the manufacturing sector. From fantastic performance improvements, at one end of the spectrum, to a decline in customer service at the other. The reasons for success and failure are varied but I have summarised some of the key reasons why I believe that these tools, techniques and approaches work in some service environments and not in others.

As the spectrum of different types of services is wide and variable, these reasons are generalised and should be seen as a summary and not definitive.

1. THE HUMAN ELEMENT IS MORE IMPORTANT IN SERVICE

The Customer Experience is key for services. How we perceive we are treated throughout the customer journey, dramatically affects our satisfaction. What may be seen as waste in manufacturing may be value to the customer such as a pleasant conversation.  Efficiency from a process perspective is not always good customer service. For most manufacturing or back office operations, this is less important as customers are not involved in the process delivery.

2. AVAILABILITY OF SERVICE DELIVERY IS KEY

Meeting peaks and troughs of customer requests as they come in is crucial for most service operations. Building stock piles is not often possible for services, while having a controlled level of inventory in manufacturing is good practice. Appointments and telephone calls cannot be stockpiled. Effective capacity management is much more relevant in service operations than, for example, supermarket inventory solutions.

3. SERVICES ARE TYPICALLY MORE DIFFICULT TO MEASURE

Let’s use a call centre process for example. The speed of processing a customer over the phone is a very poor measure, especially when providing a target to be met. It drives the agent to get customers off the line as quick as possible, potentially without answering their queries in full.  A better measure could be ‘the percentage of customer queries that can be answered in full at first point of contact’. Productivity metrics are only really relevant for processes which are repeatable in their work content. Some of these do exist in services, but they are more prevalent in manufacturing.

4. THERE IS MORE VARIETY OF DEMAND IN SERVICE

Understanding ‘failure demand’ and the associated root causes is likely to be one of the biggest levers for improvement for a service operation. Having a high number of calls in a call centre is usually a negative thing as the reason for many of them could be linked to customer chases or complaints. In manufacturing, high order levels are generally very positive and the main aim should be able to match capacity to the demand.

5. SERVICES ARE INTANGIBLE, PRODUCTS ARE TANGIBLE

Products typically are manufactured to precise specifications. They are generally made correctly or incorrectly. Standardisation can support service delivery but can also hamper it. We see standardised work in manufacturing to be the foundation for improvement, but this is not always the case in services. Standardising telephone scripts for example is more likely to frustrate a customer. For more repeatable service processes, standardised methods can however support consistent quality and efficiency if used appropriately.

6. THE ENVIRONMENT OF SERVICE DELIVERY/PRODUCTION IS MORE IMPORTANT IN SERVICE

The Customer may see the service being delivered and will make judgements based on their perception of appearance and aesthetics. Factories making products can be located anywhere in the world. Customers are unlikely to see what workers wear, hear the language they talk etc.

The principles of lean and other Operational Excellence methodologies are, without doubt, transferable across different industries. The key point that needs to be understood is the approach should be flexible as the needs of each operation is unique to them. You would not use a hammer to turn a bolt. The toolset needs to match the problem or opportunity you are targeting.

Our organisation, Reinvigoration, believes in flexibility of approach for each service operation to ensure only relevant tools and techniques are used to maximise performance improvement. We only work in services and have many different improvement approaches that complement the Operational Excellence methods that have been used in the manufacturing sectors so successfully.

Like what you’ve read? Subscribe to receive our latest case studies, articles and reports via our quaterly newsletter by entering your details in our form located at the botton of the page.

HAVE A SIMILAR CHALLENGE?

Get in touch to discuss how we can help you transform your service operations.

Chris Dando - Reinvigoration

Chris Dando

Ryan King - Reinvigoration

Ryan King

+44 (0)2921 602 182
ryan.king@reinvigoration.co.uk


Graham Turnbull - Reinvigoration

Graham Turnbull

OUR SERVICES

Throughout the years, we have developed a set of consulting, capability building and e-management solutions that enable us to tailor our approaches to our clients’ needs and help them transform their service operations.

<div id="icon-svg"><img src="https://www.reinvigoration.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/RV-Business-ConsultingConsultancy.svg" /></div>

Consultancy

We support organisations around the world in their pursuit of Operational Excellence, process change and business transformation, using innovation and cutting-edge technologies to transform
service operations.

<div id="icon-svg"><img src="https://www.reinvigoration.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/RV-Icons_Coaching.svg" /></div>

Coaching

Our approach is heavily based on knowledge transfer via coaching, so that your people are left with the skills to be self-sufficient at the end of our engagement.

<div id="icon-svg"><img src="https://www.reinvigoration.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/RV-Capability-Building.svg" /></div>

Capability Building

We have years of experience developing world class Operational Excellence and improvement skills across public and private organisations via our face-to-face and e-learning training courses.

<div id="icon-svg"><img src="https://www.reinvigoration.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/RV-E-Management-Solutions_2.svg" /></div>

E-Management Solutions

We use cutting-edge technologies to help organisations transform their service operations, become
more efficient and
increase performance.

  • NEW! Live Virtual Course - Lean Project Practitioner Course (LCS 1B/C) - 13th to 15th July 2021
    FIND OUT MORE
  • World's 1st Online BSc in Operational Excellence — In partnership with the University of Buckingham
    FIND OUT MORE
  • PUBLIC SECTOR NEWS! Procure our services without the need for a full tender
    FIND OUT MORE
  • Target Operating Model Design - The all-embracing approach
    WATCH THE WEBINAR REPLAY

ONLINE COURSE & LCS 1B/C CERTIFICATION + COACHING

Price incl. VAT: £1,620

By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by Reinvigoration Ltd as well as to receiving our newsletters and some direct emails from our team. For more information on our privacy policy please click here

LEAN PROJECT PRACTITIONER ONLINE COURSE

Price incl. VAT: £840

By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by Reinvigoration Ltd as well as to receiving our newsletters and some direct emails from our team. For more information on our privacy policy please click here

ONLINE COURSE & LCS 1B/C CERTIFICATION

Price incl. VAT: £1,140

By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by Reinvigoration Ltd as well as to receiving our newsletters and some direct emails from our team. For more information on our privacy policy please click here

DEMO - LEAN PROJECT PRACTITIONER ONLINE COURSE (LCS 1B/C)

Enter your details below to access the free demo